Humor Magazine

Cartoonmag Weekly No. 74: A House Built on Sand – Abbas Naaseri

Support feridundemir.org
Independent coverage of cartoons, cartoonists and visual satire worldwide.
Cartoonmag Weekly Weekly Single Page
Issue No. 74 · November 14, 2026

A House Built on Sand

Abbas Naaseri

No. 74 Saturday, November 14, 2026 Cartoonmag
single-page74n Cartoonmag Weekly No. 74: A House Built on Sand – Abbas Naaseri
Cartoonmag Weekly Single Page, No. 74, November 14, 2026. Original image: Cartoonmag.

A HOUSE BUILT ON SAND

Abbas Naaseri / In several judging panels I have recently been part of, one of the main topics of discussion was how to identify artworks created by artists (or rather, frauds) using artificial intelligence (AI).

One method that some judges relied on was using software that estimated the percentage of AI involvement in an artwork. In my opinion, this method was not reliable.

First, these programs had a very high error rate. Second, I believe that judges themselves should have the knowledge and skills to identify such works. They should be selected as judges because of their own expertise, not because they depend on unreliable software when making difficult decisions.

For example, when an image was created instantly by AI and tested by the software, it showed only 10% AI involvement. However, when an original image was tested, the result was 70%! Perhaps the software could identify some images correctly, but its overall error rate was so high that we could not trust it.

With these kinds of errors, fooling such software is not difficult. For example, when a social media platform removes the music from a post on a page for certain reasons, as it explains, users can trick the system by adding a very quiet background sound or noise that does not affect the music itself. In this way, they can still use that music in their posts.

The same method can be used with AI-generated images. People can add another layer over the image and then draw lines or scribbles on it. This can easily confuse the detection software.

There was also a recent case involving the Brazilian Organ Donation Festival. According to the festival’s statement, the organisers had used detection software and were sure that the winning artworks were original. However, the organisers eventually had to cancel the awards because the works had been created entirely by AI.

So, once again, the main message of this week’s article to judges and festival organisers is that they should not rely too much on this method. In some cases, they should not rely on it at all.

Imagine taking a case to a software program for a decision when the program itself is based on zeros and ones, and one side of the case is AI itself! Can we really expect a completely fair and accurate result?

If this kind of judgment and identification were possible without human knowledge and intelligence, then courts around the world should close. All respected judges should retire and stay at home, and AI software should take over their jobs!

Whenever we give an artwork to this software and wait for its opinion, we are reminded of a simple saying: “It’s like asking the fox to be its own witness!”

In my opinion, this method of detection is therefore completely unreliable.

These fraudsters are so shameless and confident that they never give up their dishonest behaviour. They continue to deny using these tools and still call themselves real artists.

(There is a story about a man who claimed to be God. He was taken before a king. The king told him: “Last year, a man came here claiming to be a prophet. We sent him to prison.”

The man replied: “You did the right thing, because I had not sent him!”)

These people never learn. Every day, they look for new tricks to fool the judges. Therefore, the most important solution is still to choose the right team of judges.

We will continue to discuss some other ways of identifying AI-generated artworks in our next issues.

—————————

Weekly Single Page of Cartoonmag
No 74
Saturday , 14 November 2026

This single page has been prepared to remind the news and calls published on the cartoon magazine website and it is supposed to be published every Saturday.

Follow the published news on our site: CARTOONMAG.COM

About the Author

Abbas Naaseri

Author of Cartoonmag’s Weekly Single Page, a regular editorial feature addressing developments, issues, and discussions within the international cartooning community.

Visit Cartoonmag

Original publication: Cartoonmag Weekly Single Page No. 74

Author: Abbas Naaseri
Original publisher: Cartoonmag
Publication date: November 14, 2026

Republished on feridundemir.org in editorial collaboration with Cartoonmag. The opinions expressed in the article belong to the original author.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button